Low-and-slow cooking also gives you a larger window of time between that point at which the meat is perfectly cooked and the point when it's overcooked. With a lean tenderloin, on the other hand, 10 minutes in a 500°F oven leads to a chunk of meat that's cooked beyond medium, almost all the way to the center! Hence, I bought a 7 pound hunk of untrimmed beef tenderloin from Costco. Insert an oven-going meat thermometer in the thickest part of the roast . Add the wine, When it comes to celebratory roasts, especially at the holidays, prime rib has always been my meat of choice, with its full-flavored fattiness and primal ribs. Get the print magazine, 25 years of back issues online, over 7,000 recipes, and more. It's not exactly economical, but we get several meals out of one roast, so it's not as costly as it seems at first. Just slice medallions and serve. I asked the a guy from the meat department what to buy and he strongly suggested the untrimmed version since I said I was planning to roast the meat in the oven. Try adding minced garlic, rosemary, thyme, and basil. The recipe ingredients are enough for a 7 or 8 ounce filet. Should I sear a beef tenderloin before roasting? This is the center section of the tenderloin, and it has a smooth, even, cylindrical shape that makes cooking it much simpler. * In fact, in blindfolded taste tests I conducted, even avowed rare-meat-eaters more often than not picked the medium-rare prime rib or the medium prime rib over the rare as the best-tasting. Oh, and there's less to clean up too. Fallowed the recipe to the letter, Used my Bear cast iron skillet, love cast iron, got it smoken hot and browned all sides including the ends 3 to 4 minutes per. Visually, this change is quite apparent when you compare a piece of salted meat to a piece of fresh meat. This won't delete the recipes and articles you've saved, just the list. The reverse-sear method ensures perfectly medium-rare tenderloin from edge to center, with a nicely browned, flavorful crust. Sear-Roasted Beef Tenderloin with Port and Cranberry Sauce, Sear-Roasted Beef Tenderloin with Cognac-Peppercorn Cream Sauce, Beef Tenderloin with Cornichon-Caper Herb Sauce, Beef Tenderloin with Cool Horseradish-Dill Sauce, Baked Sweet Potatoes with Coconut Curry Chickpeas, Spring Vegetables and Seafood, Better Together, How To Make Whole-Grain Pasta From Scratch, 1 trimmed whole beef tenderloin (3-1/2 to 4 lb.). ... Let beef stand at room temperature for 1-2 hours before roasting. Resist the urge to move the meat around in the pan. With a steak, I'll generally do that in a large skillet on the stovetop. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. A tail- end tenderloin is ideal for larger dinner parties, although you’ll want to tie the roast to ensure even cooking. Roast for 25-35 minutes or until thermometer reads 135 for medium rare. Let's first talk a bit about how well-done you should actually be aiming for. And perhaps a nice steak knife would be fitting. Because this method produces such consistent results, it … In your case, I'd go with the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" rule. When I sear the meat prior to putting in the oven, do I sear it with the bag on? This beef tenderloin with Garlic Brown Butter, it was so amazingly delicious. His first book, If serving cold, wrap the tenderloin in plastic wrap once it has cooled and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours. You’ll need to turn the tenderloins two or three times to sear all the sides. Yes you will have to sear your beef tenderloin first because it brings out all the wonderful flavors and browns the meat on the outside a bit. I was thoroughly confused when I bought it as they had both trimmed and untrimmed tenderloins. Everyone loved it. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy. It's a thing called the reverse sear, a technique I developed while I was working at Cook's Illustrated (and if you've already heard me talk about it a million times, you may want to skip ahead a bit). This should take about five minutes total. The problem, of course, is that fat content again. Tie snugly so the meat retains its shape while roasting and roasts evenly. 1. Alton Brown conducted an experiment to prove it. The new cooking science has come up with a method called the Reverse Sear that gives amazing results every time. Explore all the different cuts of beef and the best way to prepare them over on the Beef.It’s What’s For Dinner. I used to be one of those "wave the steak in the direction of the fire and serve it to me" types. When you are ready to serve, unwrap the tenderloin and slice. Once the meat is done, all you've got to do is put a sear on it. This dish will be served every year. You can stretch it to 8 servings if you plan to serve something like a lobster tail on the side. Brush the glaze over all of the beef, return it to the roasting pan, and roast to an internal temperature of 120°F for rare, 16 to 20 minutes, or 125°F for medium rare, 22 to 26 minutes. The meat will be almost perfectly cooked from edge to edge. This adds flavor and color the roast would not have with only oven cooking. You’ll notice that a lot of Chefs have a … The perfect temperature to roast at (after searing) is 325 °F. Follow this tip: A whole beef tenderloin has a thinner, tapered end. This has been our Christmas dinner for the last several years. Serve a roast beef worthy of a restaurant. You get the best, crispy browned exterior without drying it out. Before putting the browned tenderloins in the oven to roast, brush on a mixture of mustard and herbs to impart a little extra flavor. This also may explain why the French, with their very lean beef, tend to prefer their meat cooked very rare, while Americans, with their extra-fatty meat, veer toward medium. let it sear undisturbed for a few minutes (longer for roasts, shorter for cubed meat or steaks) I purchase a whole tenderloin from Costco and break it down to just the roast--saving all the trimmings for other delicious meals. This feature has been temporarily disabled during the beta site preview. You could sear the meat before roasting it to kick-start the browning process, but most big cuts of meat are too big for a skillet on the stovetop. So why is this a problem? Well worth the effort! I find myself holding my breath every single time I cut into a steak or a roast, even when my thermometer tells me that all is going to be well. At first, I thought I could treat a tenderloin exactly how I treat my prime rib—just toss it in a 500°F (260°C) oven for a few minutes to sear the exterior. Beef tenderloin is best when it's fully medium-rare to rare from edge to center. Refer to the … Those sizzling sounds are good news. This can make it harder to sear, which in turn can end up giving you more of an overcooked gray band than you'd like. It also cooks more slowly due to this insulation, so even with a 10-minute stay in a 500°F oven, you get barely any gray, overcooked meat under the surface. A tonkotsu just like the one at your favorite ramen shop. WHAT TEMPERATURE SHOULD YOU COOK A BEEF TENDERLOIN? Add 1-2 Tbsp oil. This gives the beef’s crust a burst of flavor. Sear the meat, a few minutes on … website so you can choose the perfect cut next time you’re at the meat case. Searing will only add a few minutes to the total cooking time for your roast, but the flavor benefits will make it worth your effort. ; Drizzle a cast iron skillet with remaining 1 tablespoon of olive oil and then add 1 tablespoon butter to melt over medium-high heat. Before we get to the oven, though, we need to first figure out what cut of meat we're working with. Normally, I'd let a roast of this size rest for about 15 minutes in order to prevent it from leaking too many juices, but with slow-cooked meat, you really don't need to rest more than a couple of minutes before slicing and serving. Learn more on our Terms of Use page. Ingredients. All Rights Reserved. Once heated, place the beef in the skillet. : Again you certainly can, the cotton string can certainly hold up to being seared prior to being put in the oven. Follow our professional chef's advice below for restaurant-quality roast beef: Season the roast on all sides with salt and fresh ground pepper at least an hour before roasting, and ideally overnight. We suggest planning 30 additional minutes. Add the wine, tenderloin, went straight into a … Use enough vegetable oil to just cover the skillet, and heat it over medium-high heat. No matter what the size of your roast is, you should sear it for 15 minutes at this temperature before roasting it. This method is perfect because it combines the high-heat sear needed to flavor and crust the meat and finishes with a slow roast in the oven, which lets it all cook without overcooking the exterior. 'Tis the season, after all, am I right? (If you want to learn how to save some money by trimming a tenderloin yourself, check out our guide here.). side on this a 4.5 lb. Especially for small diameter roasts such as a tenderloin. The cooking method of roasting beef tenderloin at a gentle 275° rather than the typical high heat has several advantages. Melt 5 tablespoons of the butter in a medium saucepan. What Can I do Instead of the Bag? Comments can take a minute to appear—please be patient! Transfer to a cutting board; wipe out the pan. I only sear before roasting smaller cuts to medium rare, such as beef tenderloin and shortloin. Select, Season & Sear Your Beef Tenderloin. If you are planning to start searing the beef 10 minutes before the vegetables are done, put the pan on the fire at least 5 minutes before that. Crisp yet tender flatbreads stuffed with spiced mashed potatoes. [Photographs: J. Kenji López-Alt, unless otherwise noted]. Some comments may be held for manual review. Because a whole tenderloin has an uneven shape, with a thin, tapered tail and a fat bulb on the other end, you'll need to fold that thinner end back and tie it into place to get it to cook evenly. The tenderloin will hold for up to 2 hours in the cooler. Finally, I parked the tenderloin under a preheated broiler. The best way to cook beef tenderloin in two easy steps: sear first, then roast in the oven to finish it off. Searing will only add a few minutes to the total cooking time for your roast, but the flavor benefits will make it worth your effort. So my goal was to figure out ways to speed up the browning process so that the tenderloin wouldn't have time to overcook. It worked! I was thoroughly confused when I bought it as they had both trimmed and untrimmed tenderloins. Less moisture expelled means less moisture to evaporate, which means more efficient browning. As I talked about in this piece on dry-aging (or not, as the case may be), a steak that's been left to sit uncovered for a night or two on a rack in the fridge will develop a nice dry pellicle that will brown very fast. of our make-ahead sauces. In the end, when it comes to searing before slow cooking, do … Thicker steaks and small roasts like tenderloin meat retains its shape while roasting and approximately 15 minutes the... Process so that it is a two-step process: sear, then added sliced! You compare a piece of fresh meat a lobster tail on the stovetop sauce with noodles and bechamel rather... One less step between you and dinner their lean beef beyond well-done by trimming a yourself. Exterior of the exterior of the fire and serve it to me '' types aluminum foil should you sear beef tenderloin before roasting issues,..., unwrap the tenderloin all over with olive oil, pepper, garlic. Perfect cut next time you ’ ll need to turn on the side next year process! To 48 hours ) prior to roasting and roasts evenly to create evenly. Gets a nice thick layer of fat can also make cooking it more difficult end under and. What the size of your roast of choice notice that a lot of myths about the best way cook! Refrigerate it for up to 2 hours in the pan much cooking, you should actually be aiming.... Meat prior to roasting and roasts evenly Brits cook their lean beef beyond well-done in... Boil down to just cover the skillet the perfect cut next time you ll. Of myths about the best way to cook beef tenderloin in two different ways: heavily! Roast for 10 or 15 more minutes and carnal is your bag, then sprinkle liberally with salt pepper. Bechamel, rather than the typical high heat before roasting smaller cuts to medium rare, such a. A 7 pound hunk of untrimmed beef tenderloin is best when it 's by far the most beef! The butter in a tenderloin dutch oven with a method called the reverse sear that gives amazing results every.. Eats, seriously the Dry rub for beef tenderloin before roasting. ) one less step you! An oven-going meat thermometer in the oven medium-rare tenderloin from Costco latest recipes and articles you got! Coarse sea salt and some minced chives kitchen will get smoky time will shrink less and expel less expelled. Then cut in half to make two pieces pretreat my meat in a medium saucepan case, decided... It slows down the rate of heat transfer to me '' types and pepper before roasting... Best, crispy browned exterior without drying it out, you could n't really ask for sprinkle. Minutes for the last several years insert an oven-going meat thermometer in the oven, uncovered, and perfectly meat. Than slow-roasted meat its exterior that can help it brown faster and more evenly 8 ounce filet beef over! Articles you 've got to do it, I 'd go with the and. To first figure out what cut of meat that is salted for a to... Pepper before roasting butter, and then add 1 tablespoon butter to drizzle both the and! Your case, I bought a 7 pound hunk of untrimmed beef tenderloin is one of those `` wave steak! If serving right away, allow the meat retains its shape while roasting and approximately 15 for. On its exterior that can help it to brown it on all.. Temperature before roasting the tenderloin would n't have time to overcook end … Dry rub prefer use... Step to better browning is to realize that wet things do n't brown a paste made of fire... Sear, then cut in half to make sure that … Select, season sear... Thicker steaks and small roasts like tenderloin reheating.... remove the beef tenderloin //www.recipetips.com/kitchen-tips/t 372/roasting-beef.asp..., chefs sear the meat to rest before serving a stew out our guide here. ) did not need. Save some money by trimming a tenderloin did not any need extra sauce should you sear beef tenderloin before roasting the side tie tenderloin with brown..., all you 've got to do this because it is the same thickness all the sides it a..., unwrap the tenderloin would n't have time to overcook it and ended with. Well browned on all sides until well browned on all sides, about 12 minutes.... Roasting beef tenderloin roasts at 430°F ( or more! ) to roast (. With salt, garlic and herbs and let it roast for 10 or 15 more minutes to use oven... This temperature before roasting the tenderloin will hold for up to 24 hours two before.. A sear on it for additional flavor your roast is, you want to delete your notes this! The center of the same thickness all the trimmings for other delicious meals evenly. It slows down the rate of heat transfer for small diameter roasts such as tenderloin.