201k Astrologers But people will ask, Is Astrology Really True? See the wiki page for more information. (The opening chapter of Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers makes the opposite observation, that many pro athletes have birthdays that cluster around the cutoff date that would have made them the oldest in their class). Yes, sun sign horoscopes are a complete and total sham, as using astrology to try and predict the future often is, but astrology as a whole is far more complex than a sun sign and if you look deeper into the picture, you might just find there’s a lot more “coincidences” than you think. If you are thinking about submitting a CMV yourself, please have a look through our popular topics wiki first. This is true of good opportunities as well. There's only two ways I can think of in which it's not 100% bullshit; more like 99% bullshit. In my own case I can tell you that I was born in October, and the cutoff for entering school the year I did was November 1. I'd argue that you've never seen a horoscope that says 'you'll meet the love of your life today' and that most horoscopes describe people's days. Astrology has been rejected by the scientific community as having no explanatory power for describing the universe. While I understand this point of view and it had been exposed to me in past times, unfortunately you can say this about anything. Western astrology can trace its origins back to the Babylonians. Before saying a confident "no" on certain topics I like to give them as much credibility as possible. That plan will produce the best results.". But astrology can have truth via self-fulfillment. It's like if you go into a relationship and ask, "what will this give me? It’s a crafted lie designed to fool us. Astrology, is the original science, passed down by ancient seers thousands of years ago on Vedic, being the first cosmologies through the movements, placements of the Universe. There is even gonna be a (more subtle) difference in the way of thinking and effect from a moon at 2 degrees Virgo in the 6th house vs 21.39 degrees. Secondly... we divide our calendar into years, but in the first ~10 years of life months make a big difference.   Might be, some astrologists may be using this kind of information without even realizing but seems quite unlikely for me now. Plus, theres no scientific evidence that support it. As for astrology, well, these same sorts of folks are all over that, too. But surely people do not do that "because is fun" since in the end, the main result of all that study is taking life decisions knowing those extra informations you acquired from astrology. Photographed by Rochelle Brock. As you learn more, your understanding deepens. There are also many parts on astrology that don't rely directly on this link. I think I've seen even a youtube video detailing why this is more dangerous than helpful long term. ∆ I like a lot this point of view. People rarely kill each other over their astrological sign. No, indeed. A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. Thank you. It is statistically innacurate to describe people’s traits based on their birth date and time. It’s closer to a religion, in my opinnion. Astrology can be defined as the study of the relative positions and movements of celestial objects as a means for understanding and predicting human affairs and terrestrial events. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! Theres no valid science behind it. It has been proven in numerous studies to be more accurate than placebo. Astrology (e.g., horoscope) tends to give general advice that is pretty much true for all people. They kept careful records of astronomical phe… Astrology is not a science, but there's a real, fascinating history behind humans attaching meaning to the stars. It states, “If the underlying theory of Astrology is true, that the position of the stars impacts, foretells or in any way determines … Not necessarily. It very obviously has all of jack shit to do with the position of the stars and planets. Find more subreddits like r/astrology -- A collection of links to articles on astrology, as well as discussions about astrological topics. ?” and right away completely ignore that 99% of the time it is wrong. One might think that astrology really is less harmful than the other things I listed. The ancients looked to the sky for clues about why things happened in the material world around them. Let’s get down to business. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Now you and I may not feel the need to have this belief, but that doesn't make the psychological effect of these boots bullshit. Many cultures have developed astrology systems, but the Western, Indian and … The Zodiac is based on planets not necessarily because the planets themselves have an influence, but because the movement of the planets across the sky as Earth orbits the sun is a useful way of measuring the passing of time. A person went to a buddhist for advice and began to tell him how meditation couldn't work scientifically. Still, I think going into detail to describe a person based on, for example, the time, like “you were born at 9:30am so you must be really creative!” That doesn’t hold up. Anyway, regarding your link between period of birth and astrology there could be some truth around it although if anything, it makes it even less reliable. I could not understand it, it was beyond my comprehension, but it was valuable to my belief system and I was forever changed. More from Spirit. Firstly, please remember to read through our rules. Previously I struggled in settling for POOR astrologers who had no merit or well intentions, yet now my life is far clearer because of my dearest Dawn. None whatsoever. I have, multiple times. These ancient astrologers based their interpretations on centuries of observations recorded by the Mesopotamians who came before them. The monk said, "That's true, and you cannot get any more ideas into your head unless you empty your mind of preconceived notions." Twins born one minute apart have distinct charts. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Press J to jump to the feed. First of all, this should be a … So you have a point. Enter with a mindset for conversation, not debate. I don't believe it and I was mostly hoping to get some discussions going with people actually believing to a certain degree in it. The Astrology Podcast - Chris Brennan's weekly astrology podcast is a great resource with over 100 episodes, many of which feature interviews and discussions from professionals in the field. So in a general sense it might be true that there are personality traits clustered in people born in particular months, just because so many people have been told there are and they believe it about themselves. Astrology had its heyday in the Mediterranean in the Hellenistic period, an era that took place between the 3rd century BC and the 1st century CE. I also hate it when people ask my sign and when I tell them usually (specially women) put this face like “oh I figured!” And they frame me into a stupid stereotype. So yeah it's bullshit. Don't take any offence please, but if a person is instructed to leave any preconceptions or ideas behind and just accept new ones, that is called brainwash. It shows you the ENVIRONMENT in which you are dealing with things. It is clear that this force cannot be anything already established, like gravity or light, so it must be something else. Hello, users of CMV! In fact, it is the combination of the 2 Greek words: astro, which means star and logos, which means study. I don’t think having a theory makes it real. It seems to be total bullshit. You have to have a stronger belief that something is right with what you are studying. Something about astrology is too tantalizing for people to pass up: it’s “in”, it’s perceived as harmless, and it’s fun whether or not it’s true. But it might be bullshit that once upon a time was based on a somewhat valid observation. But they will be taught the same material so seeing as they cant compete physically, December kids will focus more on studies. I want to uncover that "else" there. If you assume that the planets are the archetypes for the people who are born under their respective signs, then it's sensible to try to predict what will happen in people's lives by studying the planets. First, astrology came from vast, in depth knowledge of astronomy. The guy said, "hey you can't get any more tea in there stop!" It exists since 25,000 years ago, or probably before then. Draconic astrology is an ancient practice that is meant to give further insight into your soul. So a kid born in January, will be in the same class as a kid born in December. Astrology used to be used by farmers to know when their crops were going to come in because at particular times in the year, they can look up into the sky, see the constellation, and know whether it's time to plant, harvest etc. "Direct responses to a CMV post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s current view (however minor), unless they are asking a clarifying question. Astrology is a science that consists of a number of belief systems that hold that there is a relationship between astronomical phenomena and events … I don't think we'd be seeing such huge patterns and seeing the predictions come true if it was just rubbish. Definitely enlarged my views. You will feel much better if you get your work done first and then socialize. Disease is dis - ease. Anonymous said: Have you started to watch the true beauty drama or just the web toon? Cookies help us deliver our Services. This is completely understandable. Everyone has a different birth chart, based on the position of the stars and heavenly bodies at the time and place they were born. Astrology is based on Plato's theory of Forms, which says that everything that exists has an archetype. So people can feel like they're getting real benefit from astrology. If a horoscope is general enough to be true for all people, can you call what it says fake? It is just smoke and mirrors. They couldn't identify a single one of the zodiac constellations in the actual night sky. If I’m told as a kid that my astrological sign means I’m likely to have certain personality characteristics, and I believe it, then I might lean hard into those facets of my personality out of a false sense of destiny as I grow up. Horoscopes • Spirit • Wellness. Whether the objective is predictive or descriptive, astrology is inconsistent in fulfilling its own porpuses. Most the time it doesn’t hit anything and when it does most people are like “OMG! It fails to predict outcomes and describe personality traits and behavior accurately enough to be considered significant or useful. Where astrology has made falsifiable predictions, it has been falsified. For example, your risk of mental illness is higher if you were born in spring because your mother was more likely to get a cold or the flu during your second trimester when your brain was doing a lot of crucial development. There are three parts to any birth chart — planet, sign, and house. Your rising sign/1st house is determined by the exact couple hours you were born in on that day/in that sun cycle. my moon sits in 21.39 degrees Virgo in the 6th house, so the way my moon effects me is gonna be completely different to someone who has their moon in Leo in the 7th house, or even someone who has moon in Virgo in the 2nd house. Therefore I actually has spend some time to talk with people that practice astrology and also read about the theory and find what are their claims. So that kid who was born in January, will probably be more developed physically than the December kid. A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. I personally hate astrology, but I have a couple of friends/acquaintances/family members who are into it and from what I can tell, the attraction of astrology isn't that it can predict the future. There is no room for error when one says that the astrology as it is applied is quite bullshit. These pop culture horoscopes most people use is based on purely your sun sign and not nearly enough to determine personality traits or really almost anything future related. Maybe a person might post-pone the purchase of a house with 4 months because the planets are aligned more favourably for big decisions. I know is bogus, but I want to see the parts that actually make sense and how that 100% gets to be 80% or 60% or 50% or so. Seems more like a coincidence. This point of view actually allows me to look at astrology much more forgiving. Astrology is just a very elaborate, mystical personality test that you can manipulate to get whatever results you want. Really insightful and matches very well with my findings until now. Astrology can be baffling at first because it involves a different kind of wisdom. However, assigning traits to birth months can have some merit. I won’t tell you my sun sign. There are non-sense theories of all kinds out there. So yeah, you have to let go of toxic nonbelief in order for you to learn new things. Astrology books that promise to give relationship tips for Capricorns and Libras (or whatever) are actually just full of basic good communication advice that will probably smooth a relationship between any two people. It is written with the intent for people to buy into the idea of a fate being written out all because you were born on a certain date. Some people will jump at the chance to do something new, while others will hang back or even ignore certain possibilities. then you're not going to get anything from it. Is astrology real? In 2018, astrology became a meme, The Atlantic reports. But is there any science to back up whether astrology impacts our personality and our lives? Astrology is not predictive, that's certainly true, but if two astrologists who look at the star charts (or whatever they look at) arrive at the same conclusion, or at least do so within reasonable error margins, I'd say it's not "fake", in the sense that there's an actual theory to it. ... the largest psychic community forum on Reddit, for those interested in extrasensory perception (ESP). In that, you can already see that rising sign would be more important to the specifics of you as a person than your sun, which changes roughly every 30 days. But if you are willing to open your heart and mind there is a lot that you can benefit from. Your entire birth chart is a series of 12 houses that always starts with the first house as what you might’ve heard of as your rising sign or ascendant and houses 2-12 following in chronological order. There is fun in that. We could both agree to believe in a theory that all bald men are gay. I’m an Aquarius Sun in western astrology so I MUST be quirky and aloof right? But it's at least conceivable that our ancestors - super adept pattern recognizers that they are - did notice that people born in January seemed to have some things in common and people born in June had different things in common, and the stars in January are one way and the stars in June are another way, and thus came up with Astrology. Also stuff like: “you’ll receive a great business opportunity”, “someone will ask you for advice” stuff like that. They couldn't identify a single one of the zodiac constellations in the actual night sky. Thats huge for 5-6 year olds. My complain about those general ones is the true intentions of the people who write them. Likewise, astrology is also not parsimonious because it postulates unnecessary forces. Astrology Meaning. I don't know enough about astrology to actually say it's not fake, but I think you're asking the wrong question. There are things that are different based on when you were born. This sect of astrology can be used to further understand how you feel without the effect of any outside influences, like your personality. Edit: I may sound a bit upset, but it is not my intention. Throughout elementary school I was the youngest and smallest kid in my class. A Christian website absolutetruth.net states that Astrology is strongly condemned by the Bible as tantamount to witchcraft and occultism. It makes no sense today. Nothing really "false" here. Arguments in favor of the view OP is willing to change must be restricted to replies to comments." The meaning of Astrology shows the “study of stars” However I think you have to be careful with saying that it is 100% bullshit. If you would like to appeal, please [message the moderators by clicking this link.](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fchangemyview&subject=Removed+Comment+Rule+1+Post+Appeal&message=Mostly-Ponies+would+like+to+appeal+the+removal+of+his/her+post. It makes some sense that what month you're born is going to have some impact on your social development and consequently your personality. Sorry Mostly-Ponies, your comment has been removed: Comment Rule 1. Is Astrology True? For every generic daily message awaiting you, there is a bored person writing for Horoscopes.com that has no credibility. However I know there are people (smart people that is) who study these kind of things and I would love to get my view changed on this one. written by Sara Coughlin. I think there is nothing that could potentially be true in astrology. It's really not that different from the MBTI personality test, which is extremely popular among "rational" people even though it's junk science. Actually, I have read that seasonality may affect the parents emotional state during the child’s first months, and that MAY have a slight impact in the child’s personality. You know no REAL magic is being performed, and it's an illusion - but it's still good entertainment. This is a footnote from your moderators. It was a true, real, and life-transforming experience to me. The attraction of astrology is that it's an elaborate personality test that encourages a lot of self-reflective navel-gazing, which some people enjoy and find beneficial. I felt like there was no one there and no true answers to cure my pain and Dawn Anne showed up for ME. You have to try it yourself and really give yourself to the process. I myself have had my chart read many times and it's too accurate to be coincidence. "You might want to engage in just about every activity except work. People said the same about all kind of topics in the past that are now common knowledge.